The graveyard of good ideas
Solutions that were tried, and what stopped them.
Patents that were rejected or abandoned, products that shut down, projects that went quiet. Borrow the idea, avoid the dead end.
3,400 solutions
- startupShut down2009
Ask HN: Am I crazy?
So I just graduated college in the spring and I have about $1500 in savings that I could spend on the deposit + rent/moving expenses for an apartment somewhere and continue looking for a job, but something in me is telling me there's a better way. I have a plan, but I want to see if you guys think I'm crazy (If HN thinks it's too out there, then I know I'm off-base) or if I'm going to need more money or what. I have known for some time that there's something different in the brain of an entrepreneur that changes the way they see the world, and I want to find out what that is. So I want to set out to find entrepreneurs, either through appointment or serendipity, and spend a little time with them. Just get to know how they decided to do what they do, what keeps them going, what their hopes and dreams are, etc. I posit that there's commonalities to be found there and a lot of insight to be
Why it failed: So I just graduated college in the spring and I have about $1500 in savings that I could spend on the deposit + rent/moving expenses for an apartment somewhere and continue looking for a job, but something in me is telling me there's a better way. I have a plan, but I want to see
amohr
- startupShut down2009
What should I choose, PhD or startup?
Recently, I was asked by a professor to advice his student, whether to pursue his idea/startup (a chemical product, he invented) or go for a Ph.D. degree in chemistry eng.. The professor chose to ask me, because I both have a PhD degree and multiple startup experience. In my answer I didn't focus so much on the basics (business plan etc.), figuring he already knows most of this, but more on how to choose. Do you like/agree with my answer ? ------ Hello, The pros of a PhD degree: A PhD degree does sometimes give you access and credibility to venture into bigger ideas. However, there is no guarantees. You could choose to finish your PhD degree and enter or found a highfuelled venture later on, such as those founded by www.kpcb.com or www.sequoiacap.com (these are most successfull and well-known ones, there are of course many smaller). Personally, it might give you the aptitude to write bet
Why it failed: Recently, I was asked by a professor to advice his student, whether to pursue his idea/startup (a chemical product, he invented) or go for a Ph.D. degree in chemistry eng.. The professor chose to ask me, because I both have a PhD degree and multiple startup experience. In my answ
teralaser
- startupShut down2009
The RE: 4chan email that is going around AT&T HQ
When the AT&T 4chan episode hit the internet I had posted on HN that I would tell my contact there what is going on. My contact sent me this today. It is the email going around at AT&T HQ explaining what the 4chan episode was all about. I thought it was interesting to see the nature of articles that large corporations choose to send around. ---begin--- AT&T: 4Chan Blocked Over DDoS, Not Content Jordan Golson | Monday, July 27, 2009 | 10:22 AM PT | 3 comments AT&T has finally issued a statement about the company’s unannounced blocking of certain parts of forum site 4Chan. A number of parties blamed AT&T for “censoring” the Internet, presuming that the company had blocked access because of the content on 4Chan, which can range from classless to tasteless to everything in between. In fact, AT&T said it blocked one section of the site to control a distributed-denial-o
Why it failed: When the AT&T 4chan episode hit the internet I had posted on HN that I would tell my contact there what is going on. My contact sent me this today. It is the email going around at AT&T HQ explaining what the 4chan episode was all about. I thought it was interesting to see
3pt14159
- startupShut down2008
YouOS (winter 07) shutting down?
:( Correction: That's Winter 06.
Why it failed: :( Correction: That's Winter 06.
sown
- startupShut down2008
Ask YC: What do I do with an unproductive co-founder, 12+ months in?
"I release you, Ebenezer" Things have gotten rough for our little company over the last few months. We pushed to meet a market deadline, and stressed out both myself and my cofounder; What's more painful is that we strained our budgets- Putting him on Full time development for a few months, and taking out loans to finance the other development we needed. Unfortuantely, since June or so, he hasn't been holding up his side of the company. He's written less than 100 lines of code in 4 months. Although we've been friends for nearly 10 years, I had to call him last night, and tell him I wanted to buy him out. The way I see it, there are really only two options- * I buy him out, and try to develop on my own, possibly taking on a new co-founder.. * I abandon the project, pay off the loans, and lick my wounds, sacrificing the company, and my own financial health for the friendship. It's stressfu
Why it failed: "I release you, Ebenezer" Things have gotten rough for our little company over the last few months. We pushed to meet a market deadline, and stressed out both myself and my cofounder; What's more painful is that we strained our budgets- Putting him on Full time development for a
SirName
- startupShut down2008
Using Dropbox to Track Bugs
Being a tiny startup looking for ways to save money, we discovered the best, cheapest bug tracking software out there. It's dropbox (or dropbugz). Simply make a folder called "bugs" in your dropbox and put a "done" directory in it. -Each bug is a .txt file whose name is the description of the bug. -Dropbox keeps track of who creates / edits files so if someone botches a description you can always figure out who wrote it up and when. (Unix does a decent job of this too.) -You can assign bugs by putting "#fixer_name" at the top of the file and grepping for "#fixer_name" on the command line. -When bugs are done you move them to the "done" folder. If you duplicate a title it overwrites, but dropbox has your back w/ revision edits. -You can preform any sort of command line voodoo to slice and dice your bugs. -You know when bugs are posted or fixed through the dropbox notifications. -You never
Why it failed: Being a tiny startup looking for ways to save money, we discovered the best, cheapest bug tracking software out there. It's dropbox (or dropbugz). Simply make a folder called "bugs" in your dropbox and put a "done" directory in it. -Each bug is a .txt file whose name is the descr
uuilly
- startupShut down2008
Ask YC: Ethical Question, possible fraud
Background Info: I am a coder at an angel backed startup.. we have a couple paying customers and a handful of full time employees including a few founders. I started a few months ago after i saw an ad for the job, I did not know the founders previously, the company has been around for about 2 years. We sell software to fairly large corporations. Ethical Dilemma: The past couple weeks, I have overheard the founder of the company exagerrate/lie about key facts of our company to potential customers. ie. claiming that we have 20 customers worldwide. claiming the we have multiple offices. and 2-3 times the employees that we actually have. claiming that certain parts of the software are in use by other customers when these parts have never been used in production.. not positive about this but possibly misrepresenting investment incoming money as sales in financial due diligence documents or at
Why it failed: Background Info: I am a coder at an angel backed startup.. we have a couple paying customers and a handful of full time employees including a few founders. I started a few months ago after i saw an ad for the job, I did not know the founders previously, the company has been aroun
nobodynew
- startupShut down2008
Ask HN: The curse of the green card: entrepreneurship for immigrants?
Background: I am from India. I have a PhD in engineering (Berkeley) and a steady full time job at a tech company in the valley. I work on an H1B visa and my green card application has been filed (EB2, pending AOS, received EAD). Problem: I’ve been hacking at a startup concept for a few months now. We (my "co-founders" are also immigrants) are now at a point where we have a well functioning product and eager customers. The only thing that is preventing us from going live is incorporation (which gives us the ability to accept payments, liability protection, IP, etc). Being temporary immigrant workers on an H1B we can incorporate and "own" a company ... but CANNOT WORK for it. o How do immigrants handle such a quandary? o Yes, I can own a large % of equity, but I can’t write a single line of code... because that would technically be "working" for the company and could increase the value of
Why it failed: Background: I am from India. I have a PhD in engineering (Berkeley) and a steady full time job at a tech company in the valley. I work on an H1B visa and my green card application has been filed (EB2, pending AOS, received EAD). Problem: I’ve been hacking at a startup concept for
stevesmith155
- startupShut down2008
Ask YC: Competitor flying under us...
DISCLAIMER: This is kinda long, but if you take the time to read it I will buy you a karma lollipop. I remember distinctly reading one of PG's maxims: Never let anybody fly underneath you. And we never have. We are a low cost provider of a hotly demanded product that appeals to public/overnment clients. These particular entities usually pay anywhere between $100K and $20M to have this type of system installed, and can pay ongoing fees anywhere from $500 a month to $500K a year, depending on the size of the organization being outfitted. Suffice it to say that there is a huge market for this product...many many of these organizations all dying to have the product. We have done well with well over $500K in revenue in <2 years, no funding, and a win in a big name startup contest that netted us $100K in cash and prizes out of 250 entrants we competed against. There are about 6 competitors
Why it failed: DISCLAIMER: This is kinda long, but if you take the time to read it I will buy you a karma lollipop. I remember distinctly reading one of PG's maxims: Never let anybody fly underneath you. And we never have. We are a low cost provider of a hotly demanded product that appeals to p
theyoungceo
- startupShut down2008
My side project: an open-sourced comedy community
Hi everyone, I just launched a side project I've been working on for the last month or so ... it's fairly simple, but I'd love your thoughts. http://www.ChompChompDead.com --> it's roughly what happens when you get eaten by a shark. We like to think of it as open-sourced comedy. Anyways, there's a cast of 10 members who submit articles that are rated by the public. At the end of each week, the lowest rated cast member gets demoted, while the funniest member of the community is promoted. Basically, this is one of those 'life is too short' kind of initiatives. I just love writing and reading comedy, nothing existed like this before, I knew I could build it... so I did. I'm not really expecting to profit off of it -- I merely wanted it to exist. I'm launching it with the help of a bunch of screenwriters and comics I know. It's amazing how much the creative world doesn't understand about
Why it failed: Hi everyone, I just launched a side project I've been working on for the last month or so ... it's fairly simple, but I'd love your thoughts. http://www.ChompChompDead.com --> it's roughly what happens when you get eaten by a shark. We like to think of it as open-sourced come
parker
- startupShut down2008
Are these founders trying to screw me?
I've been working for a startup for about a year now. I've written many thousands of lines of code for them. The founder has lied to me several times, gone ballistic on me and is one of those ultra paranoid crazies. If I knew this about him when I started I would never have worked for him. I've been promised a large amount of stock months ago and haven't received my stock agreement yet. We now have a well known investor that has just agreed to invest. Over the past few months I've been told "hey your stock agreement is coming". Then the other day I get handed some paperwork to sign: NDA and contract. They say "sign these and you'll get your stock agreement". The problem is that the contract is outrageous and takes away every right I have. Clearly I'm not going to sign it. I just want to know what's in my stock agreement and they're telling me "hey that's up to the investor and his law fi
Why it failed: I've been working for a startup for about a year now. I've written many thousands of lines of code for them. The founder has lied to me several times, gone ballistic on me and is one of those ultra paranoid crazies. If I knew this about him when I started I would never have worke
readyrnot
- startupShut down2008
Ask YC: prove commitment within two months?
I am worried that my CV doesn't really mark me as the ideal founder. It seems to me I wasted so much time in my life (35 years old now), and even the projects I finished successfully (most I didn't finish) usually took too long, and did not reach the scope I was hoping for. In essence, there are not many achievements I am really proud about. It might just be my personal assessment, but still (agents love my Java consulting CV, but it doesn't mean anything to me). I have even publicly admitted to burnout syndromes on HN - big red flag? My karma also shows that I procrastinate a lot... Anyway, I wonder about your opinions: is it possible to turn around that impression within two months, which is the time I could hopefully dedicate to preparing the next YC application? I suppose the obvious path to take is to work on a demo day and night, and anyway, giving up is not an option (I might just
Why it failed: I am worried that my CV doesn't really mark me as the ideal founder. It seems to me I wasted so much time in my life (35 years old now), and even the projects I finished successfully (most I didn't finish) usually took too long, and did not reach the scope I was hoping for. In es
Tichy
- startupShut down2008
Ask HN: How can one deal with bad management?
I'm working at a big and renowned software company, but I'm not living in the USA, so my experience could be different from people working there. After all, big companies only come in third-world countries for cost-savings. I also read pg's essays, which I liked, so I may be influenced by his thinking. I am a regular software developer, and I'm really passionate about my work, that's why it hurts me to no end when I see decisions being made that do not benefit the project. Some gripes include, but not limited to: * changing a good design with one that's not visually appealing, and is really confusing, because we had to make it look like it's part of the company's website * to change the design, and to accomodate future changes, we are including external server-side files in our HTML, files that gathered a lot of cruft over the years, with bad coding practices (inline CSS/Javascript). We
Why it failed: I'm working at a big and renowned software company, but I'm not living in the USA, so my experience could be different from people working there. After all, big companies only come in third-world countries for cost-savings. I also read pg's essays, which I liked, so I may be infl
bad_user
- startupShut down2008
Ask YC: Hiring a Freelancer with High Rates
I'm about to hire a guy to add to the team who currently lives in the world of high-end, expensive freelancing. Salary isn't very flexible since we're working on somewhat of a budget, and remaining conservative with our funds. Currently his hourly rates are above what we're capable of meeting, but he remained optimistic about negotiations. Have any of you gone through a circumstance like this, and if so what were your experiences in the long run?
Why it failed: I'm about to hire a guy to add to the team who currently lives in the world of high-end, expensive freelancing. Salary isn't very flexible since we're working on somewhat of a budget, and remaining conservative with our funds. Currently his hourly rates are above what we're capab
iamdave
- startupShut down2008
Rebuttal to "A hacker's loneliness"
I too "wasted" most of my teens writing "pointless" programs - games in Basic that I never finished, assembly language programs optimized for old computers 20 years obsolete, and C++ programs with extensible architectures that no one else will ever extend. My father always warned me that one day I would wake up and realize I'd wasted my life sitting in front of a computer screen. Bullshit. When I was in college I ran into people I'd known in high school who told me some stories about what was really going on in the social circles I'd missed while I spent my days with a computer, and I was shocked. Most of my "normal" peers who had social lives drank heavily and got into drugs - some died or nearly died. Many of them became teen parents. I never even knew! My obsession with computers had kept me insulated from all of that. Now that I'm a working adult and married, I look back with wonder
Why it failed: I too "wasted" most of my teens writing "pointless" programs - games in Basic that I never finished, assembly language programs optimized for old computers 20 years obsolete, and C++ programs with extensible architectures that no one else will ever extend. My father always warned
phaedrus
- startupShut down2008
Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham
I do not remember my parents ever lying to me, and I have tried to always tell my children the truth as well. I never remember my parents swearing at anyone or about anything. They were honest when they were angry or upset, but did not feel it was helpful to get demeaning or curse things or people. I have also tried to help my children work out their problems and anger without resorting to shouting or swearing, because I agree that the escalation is more hurtful than helpful. We don't always succeed, but that is the goal. When our textbooks glossed over the truth or TV programs misrepresented reality, my parents pointed it out. I have done the same with my children. When we asked about sex, drugs, alcohol, my parents explained it straightforwardly and also explained why they had chosen to remain virgins until married, and not risk addiction to mind-alerting substances (or even health-alt
Why it failed: I do not remember my parents ever lying to me, and I have tried to always tell my children the truth as well. I never remember my parents swearing at anyone or about anything. They were honest when they were angry or upset, but did not feel it was helpful to get demeaning or curs
hesid
- startupShut down2008
Ask HN: Rate my startup (video)
http://vimeo.com/2231638 Would love to know what you guys think. Beware of the discontinuity @ 6:44 :) Sorry, no public demo available (yet).
Why it failed: http://vimeo.com/2231638 Would love to know what you guys think. Beware of the discontinuity @ 6:44 :) Sorry, no public demo available (yet).
cte
- startupShut down2008
Shoestring Budget? Starting to feel growth issues on your back-end? Embrace unix and C
I'm one of the co-founders of Media Wombat ( flash search engine at http://mediawombat.com ) and we're a startup that's about 8 months old. We have no funding except what we can afford to do ourselves, no investors and very little spare hardware. Our site is a search engine - like google, but for flash content. We threw together the site in a weekend and have been slowly tweaking it over time but recently have run into some growth issues. If you have funding or investors and have growth issues, you can just throw more hardware at the problem and ta-da! You're fast again. However, for those of us who don't have money being thrown at us, we have to be a little more creative and start to look at optimization. I've got a couple of old machines and an 8-drive SCSI RAID in my basement that I'm using for our search engine to crawl the web and process the data that we index for our search engine
Why it failed: I'm one of the co-founders of Media Wombat ( flash search engine at http://mediawombat.com ) and we're a startup that's about 8 months old. We have no funding except what we can afford to do ourselves, no investors and very little spare hardware. Our site is a search engine - lik
scumola
- startupShut down2008
Solicit YC
I hope you are not put off by the title. But I want you to offer me for a few weeks. Do you know of a place where I can work as an intern this summer? Preferably your own startup. I can start as soon as July 14 and would like to end in mid October as the latest. I study math at Magdeburg University, Germany. Currently I live in Ankara, Turkey, for a semester abroad. I would not mind travelling around the world for the internship. I have strong background in mathematical optimization and computational aspects of math. I have also picked up stochastic and did recently formalize my interest in economics and finance. The Germany study system is a bit strange - basically you can regard my as a graduate student. My university requires me to write a seminar paper ('Studienarbeit') about my internship. So my field of work has to be related to math - or even better to optimization. Do you think y
Why it failed: I hope you are not put off by the title. But I want you to offer me for a few weeks. Do you know of a place where I can work as an intern this summer? Preferably your own startup. I can start as soon as July 14 and would like to end in mid October as the latest. I study math at M
eru
- startupShut down2008
One (programming) language for the rest of your life. Which one?
If you had to pick one single computer language to use from now until the end of time, which one would you pick? What qualities are you looking for? What are your programming goals? If you like, you can specify a platform or libraries if they colored your choice of language.
Why it failed: If you had to pick one single computer language to use from now until the end of time, which one would you pick? What qualities are you looking for? What are your programming goals? If you like, you can specify a platform or libraries if they colored your choice of language.
watmough
- startupShut down2008
Trader Joe's Is Not Your Average Business (2002)
One day a few years ago, a guy at a Boston financial firm called up Trader Joe's headquarters and said he'd like to tour a store with a group of visiting Japanese investors. The brass at Trader Joe's was blunt: "You can't come." Not "We'd rather you didn't," or "Please don't." The visit was officially forbidden. This led to a predictable go-round about it being a free country and all, and Trader Joe's finally said okay, okay, you can come, but you don't get a tour. And as the investment company guy tells it, the tension in the air during the visit was thick enough to cut with a machete. Well, you probably can't blame the folk at Trader Joe's. They've got a phenomenal thing going, and don't want to give it all away. Some observers think that sales per square foot at Trader Joe's are hovering at about $1,000 -- twice the level of typical supermarkets. And with between about 70% to 85% of i
Why it failed: One day a few years ago, a guy at a Boston financial firm called up Trader Joe's headquarters and said he'd like to tour a store with a group of visiting Japanese investors. The brass at Trader Joe's was blunt: "You can't come." Not "We'd rather you didn't," or "Please don't." Th
daveambrose
- startupShut down2008
Anywhere.FM acquired by imeem
We are very excited to announce that Anywhere.FM has been acquired by imeem (http://www.imeem.com), the leading social media network. Since our launch last August, Anywhere.FM has been dedicated to making it easy to upload, play, and share your music wherever you go. We have listened to our users and worked hard to provide them with the best music playback experience available on the Internet. The millions of tracks that our users have uploaded to Anywhere.FM over the last 6 months prove to us that we have been successful in achieving this goal. Today's announcement broadens the scope of Anywhere.FM's ambitions, bringing us together with imeem, a social networking site with a media-centric approach to connecting consumers. With imeem, users can enjoy, recommend and discover not only music, but film, video, TV programming and art, and connect with people who share similar tastes. Anywhere
Why it failed: We are very excited to announce that Anywhere.FM has been acquired by imeem (http://www.imeem.com), the leading social media network. Since our launch last August, Anywhere.FM has been dedicated to making it easy to upload, play, and share your music wherever you go. We have list
iamwil
- startupShut down2008
Ask YC: Story for Forbes - What really happens when your startup fails?
The last few inquiries I did on HN for Forbes stories had great results. Would love to hear from you guys on this one... I'm writing a story for Forbes about what really happens when your startup company fails. I need to hear from entrepreneurs who have had failing startup companies with an honest explanation of how they were affected financially and emotionally. The story looks to explore the difference between what potential entrepreneurs expect to go wrong and what really happens. This isn't a postmortem on why your startup failed - it's a short summary of what was lost in the process and how you dealt with that loss. Some basic questions - - How did you expect the first few years of your startup company to go? - What did you risk to launch your startup? - What do you felt you lost when your startup company failed? - How did you recoup from this loss? - What advice would you give aspi
Why it failed: The last few inquiries I did on HN for Forbes stories had great results. Would love to hear from you guys on this one... I'm writing a story for Forbes about what really happens when your startup company fails. I need to hear from entrepreneurs who have had failing startup compan
wschroter
- startupShut down2008
My Startup: app turns music discovery into an online game - feedback?
www.thesixtyone.com what? thesixtyone, a web game that makes listening to new music a fun, adventurous experience. It's like a music scout role-playing game. how? Listeners are allocated virtual currency that they can spend promoting songs and are rewarded when their picks perform well. Top songs reach the homepage and are sorted into a radio playlist where listeners are a click away from discovering new sounds. status We're 3 months into our public beta, and, aside from balancing several "gameplay" mechanics, we've since introduced a couple of new features, including a more sophisticated genre system, show listings, artist photo reels, play history, and embeddable listener badges that syndicate your personal radio station across the web. about thesixtyone is myself and Sam Hsiung. I used to be a game developer (EA/Atari/Activision), but declined an offer to work on Xbox Live (my dream j
Why it failed: www.thesixtyone.com what? thesixtyone, a web game that makes listening to new music a fun, adventurous experience. It's like a music scout role-playing game. how? Listeners are allocated virtual currency that they can spend promoting songs and are rewarded when their picks perfor
JMiao