IssueRaiser

I think the biggest problem with Unikernels that I haven't seen addressed is hypervisor inefficiency.

I think the biggest problem with Unikernels that I haven't seen addressed is hypervisor inefficiency. Emulating any part of a kernel or multiple kernels will just be slower. You have 20 guests on your hosts? That's 20 probably-overlapping (uni)kernels running. Sure you could optimize the heck out of the hypervisor, but now you've created a kernel. And your applications run on that kernel. With containers, you have one kernel that won't have to instantiate 20 drivers for the disk subsystem. It can be smarter because it knows more about the loads. It's what kernels have been built to do since day 0. My main concern with unikernels is that eventually the hypervisor will need to be a kernel to be any more optimized. I just worry it will be come something of a self-defeating concept.

Posted by andrewstuart2 on Nov 14, 2014, 9:22 PM

Tags

Related issues

Raise real-world problems, find people facing the same issue, and discuss solutions.9,000 issues0 comments

hackernews (Other)

I think the biggest problem with Unikernels that I haven't seen addressed is hypervisor inefficiency.

andrewstuart2Nov 14, 2014, 9:22 PM

I think the biggest problem with Unikernels that I haven't seen addressed is hypervisor inefficiency. Emulating any part of a kernel or multiple kernels will just be slower. You have 20 guests on your hosts? That's 20 probably-overlapping (uni)kernels running. Sure you could optimize the heck out of the hypervisor, but now you've created a kernel. And your applications run on that kernel. With containers, you have one kernel that won't have to instantiate 20 drivers for the disk subsystem. It can be smarter because it knows more about the loads. It's what kernels have been built to do since day 0. My main concern with unikernels is that eventually the hypervisor will need to be a kernel to be any more optimized. I just worry it will be come something of a self-defeating concept.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the discussion.

Comment on this issue