IssueRaiser

Atatürk gave Turkey a lot of great things.

Atatürk gave Turkey a lot of great things. The alphabet isn't one of them. The dotted/dotless "i" in Turkish is just plain broken and there's no way to support it without 100% confidence in the text's language (which is impossible in the real world because multi-language users are a thing). For anyone not familiar with the problem, the two variants of the letter "i" in Turkish are considered two separate letters but neither the dotless nor the dotted "i" is compatible with the non-Turkish "i" in lower and upper case: * the lower case of upper case "I" is the dotless "ı" (not "i" as everywhere else) * the upper case of lower case "i" is the dotted "İ" (not "I" as everywhere else) This is basically a bug in the original specification (ca. 19th century) that was never fixed and now causes all kinds of problems for anyone trying to support it (because languages no longer live in isolation).

Posted by pluma on Jul 17, 2015, 8:08 AM

Tags

Related issues

Raise real-world problems, find people facing the same issue, and discuss solutions.5,500 issues0 comments

reliability (Other)

Atatürk gave Turkey a lot of great things.

plumaJul 17, 2015, 8:08 AM

Atatürk gave Turkey a lot of great things. The alphabet isn't one of them. The dotted/dotless "i" in Turkish is just plain broken and there's no way to support it without 100% confidence in the text's language (which is impossible in the real world because multi-language users are a thing). For anyone not familiar with the problem, the two variants of the letter "i" in Turkish are considered two separate letters but neither the dotless nor the dotted "i" is compatible with the non-Turkish "i" in lower and upper case: * the lower case of upper case "I" is the dotless "ı" (not "i" as everywhere else) * the upper case of lower case "i" is the dotted "İ" (not "I" as everywhere else) This is basically a bug in the original specification (ca. 19th century) that was never fixed and now causes all kinds of problems for anyone trying to support it (because languages no longer live in isolation).

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the discussion.

Comment on this issue