IssueRaiser

As much as I hate that sceintific papers don't give good introductions to the public, specialists do have their values.

As much as I hate that sceintific papers don't give good introductions to the public, specialists do have their values. An educated, intelligent reader has limits when it comes to frontline research. It is like asking someone flying a 787 jetliner without touching an airplane before. Prior knowledge and experience are important. What I absolutely reject is false exclusivity that some scientists hide behind. A professional statistician can spot statistical errors even if he or she never did any cancer study before. A rational person can discern the trustworth of a scientific report if enough details and background are well explained. I always find that popular press lacks a degree of healthy comptempt for specialists. It actually has improved somewhat recently. Still sometimes newspaper reports read like press release.

Posted by east2west on Aug 3, 2014, 3:10 PM

Tags

Related issues

Raise real-world problems, find people facing the same issue, and discuss solutions.9,500 issues0 comments

complaint (Other)

As much as I hate that sceintific papers don't give good introductions to the public, specialists do have their values.

east2westAug 3, 2014, 3:10 PM

As much as I hate that sceintific papers don't give good introductions to the public, specialists do have their values. An educated, intelligent reader has limits when it comes to frontline research. It is like asking someone flying a 787 jetliner without touching an airplane before. Prior knowledge and experience are important. What I absolutely reject is false exclusivity that some scientists hide behind. A professional statistician can spot statistical errors even if he or she never did any cancer study before. A rational person can discern the trustworth of a scientific report if enough details and background are well explained. I always find that popular press lacks a degree of healthy comptempt for specialists. It actually has improved somewhat recently. Still sometimes newspaper reports read like press release.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the discussion.

Comment on this issue