IssueRaiser

In the Brumadinho case, five engineers were arrested and charged and jailed.

In the Brumadinho case, five engineers were arrested and charged and jailed. They are out of jail and a criminal case is ongoing. In the Bhopal disaster, seven engineers and executives were convicted of causing death by negligence and give the maximum penalty (which was pretty weak). The Chernobyl incident led to Anatoly Dyatlov to be jailed and getting a 10-year sentence. For Fukushima, some people were charged with professional negligence causing death but they beat the charges in court. Licensing will not make anybody competent. But it can help keep incompetent people out of our field. When Engineers screw up, their malpractice insurance may get too expensive for them to continue to work in the field. When management asks for something unethical, it gives a pretty good reason for pushing back.

Posted by criddell on Oct 2, 2025, 2:59 PM

Tags

Related issues

Raise real-world problems, find people facing the same issue, and discuss solutions.2,000 issues0 comments

pricing (Other)

In the Brumadinho case, five engineers were arrested and charged and jailed.

criddellOct 2, 2025, 2:59 PM

In the Brumadinho case, five engineers were arrested and charged and jailed. They are out of jail and a criminal case is ongoing. In the Bhopal disaster, seven engineers and executives were convicted of causing death by negligence and give the maximum penalty (which was pretty weak). The Chernobyl incident led to Anatoly Dyatlov to be jailed and getting a 10-year sentence. For Fukushima, some people were charged with professional negligence causing death but they beat the charges in court. Licensing will not make anybody competent. But it can help keep incompetent people out of our field. When Engineers screw up, their malpractice insurance may get too expensive for them to continue to work in the field. When management asks for something unethical, it gives a pretty good reason for pushing back.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the discussion.

Comment on this issue